Lakhlani International
Startup Ecosystem

How to Prepare for a Mentoring Session: Objective, Assumptions, Options and Next Steps

Two people can walk into the same mentoring conversation and leave with very different results. The difference is rarely the mentor. It is usually how clearly the person arrived: with a specific decision, honest context and a readiness to be challenged, or with a general sense that things are hard and some hope that advice will help.

This article gives a practical template for preparing. It builds on what Lakhlani International's Leadership Mentoring page says about preparing (bring one or two decisions, the relevant context, options considered and constraints) and on its four-step method.

Why preparation matters

A short session is a limited resource. Without preparation, much of it goes to explaining the background, and the hardest question gets asked in the last five minutes. The capability page is clear about what a useful session looks like: it starts with a real decision or capability gap and ends with clear next steps, not generic motivation.

Research hints at why the mentee's side matters. A longitudinal study of novice entrepreneurs by Étienne St-Jean and Maripier Tremblay found that mentoring supported one measure of entrepreneurial confidence only for mentees low in learning goal orientation, and that the effect faded once the relationship ended. A separate study by St-Jean, Miruna Radu-Lefebvre and Cynthia Mathieu of 360 novice Canadian entrepreneurs found that more in-depth mentoring was associated with lower confidence among mentees high in learning goal orientation. The authors read this partly as mentoring helping people calibrate to a more realistic level, not as harm. These are specific findings from specific samples; their limits are discussed in the companion article on whether mentoring works. The practical point is that what you bring, and how you use the session, shapes what you get.

The one-page brief

Write a brief of one page or less, and share it before the session if the mentor accepts one. Use these headings.

1. Objective

What do you want to leave with? Be concrete. "Choose between two options for the next quarter" is an objective. "Get advice on growth" is a topic.

2. Context

In a few lines: what the business or team does, its stage, the people involved and what has happened recently. The Quick Connect description on the Lakhlani International page suggests summarising the venture, stage, main obstacle and the decision you need help with, which is a good minimal version.

3. The decision or gap

State it as a choice, a question or a capability you want to build. If there are several, rank them and bring one or two. The page advises exactly that.

4. Options you have considered

List at least two, including doing nothing. For each, note the main argument for and against. If you have only one option, that is itself a finding.

5. Facts and assumptions

Two short lists. What you know, with evidence. What you are assuming, with how confident you are. The capability method names this step: clarify facts, assumptions and constraints.

6. Constraints

Time, money, people, skills, commitments and anything you cannot change. A mentor cannot give useful advice about options you could not actually take.

7. What you want challenged

Name the part of your thinking you are least sure of. Inviting challenge in advance makes it easier for both sides.

8. Success signals

How will you know, in a few weeks, whether the session helped? A decision made, a test designed, a conversation held.

A brief might fit on one page like this.

Template headings and what to enter

  • →Objective. What you want to leave with.
  • →Context. Venture, stage, people, recent events.
  • →Decision or gap. The choice or capability, ranked.
  • →Options. At least two, with for and against.
  • →Facts. What you know, with evidence.
  • →Assumptions. What you believe, with confidence.
  • →Constraints. Time, money, people, skills.
  • →Challenge me on. Where you are least sure.
  • →Success signals. What will show it helped.

During the session

The four steps on the capability page give a natural shape.

  1. Set the objective and context. Restate your objective in a sentence and check the mentor shares it.
  2. Clarify facts, assumptions and constraints. Expect questions. Answer them plainly, and note where you realise you do not know.
  3. Explore options and trade-offs. Resist defending your first idea. Ask the mentor how they would think about the trade-offs and what they have seen go wrong.
  4. Agree actions and the evidence needed to assess progress. End by stating what you will do, by when and how you will know if it worked.

Useful questions to ask a mentor:

  • →What would you want to know before deciding this?
  • →What have you seen go wrong in similar situations?
  • →What would make you change your mind?
  • →What am I not asking that I should be?
  • →If you were in my position, what would you test first?

After the session

This is where value is often lost. Within a day, write down:

  • →The decision or direction you reached, in a sentence.
  • →The actions, with owners and dates.
  • →The evidence you will gather and the checkpoint at which you will review it.
  • →Questions to follow up, or resources the mentor suggested.

The capability page lists practical next steps and decision checkpoints, and follow-up questions or resources appropriate to the agreed goal, among the things you receive. Capture them while they are fresh, and put the review date in your calendar.

Common mistakes

  • →Arriving with a topic, not a decision. The session becomes a general chat.
  • →Hiding the awkward facts. Advice is only as good as the information behind it.
  • →Defending, not exploring. If you only argue for your plan, you waste the challenge.
  • →Treating advice as instructions. The decision stays yours.
  • →Skipping the follow-through. Without actions and checkpoints, little changes.
  • →Expecting regulated advice. Mentoring is not a substitute for qualified legal, tax, investment or other regulated professional advice.

An illustrative scenario (hypothetical)

Consider a hypothetical technology lead preparing for a session about whether to rebuild a core module or extend it. Her brief states the objective (decide for the next two quarters), the context (a seed-stage product with eight paying customers), the two options with arguments, the assumption she is least sure of (that the rebuild would cut support load), the constraints (two engineers, no new hires) and what she wants challenged (her estimate).

The session spends most of its time on the estimate and on a cheap way to test the support-load assumption before deciding. She leaves with two actions and a checkpoint in three weeks. The mentor did not decide for her. The preparation turned a vague worry into a testable choice. This scenario is invented for illustration and does not describe any client.

Next step

Copy the template above, fill in the objective and the decision first, and keep the rest short. If it takes more than a page, you probably have more than one decision, so pick the most important one.

When you are ready for a conversation, you can book a Startups: Quick Connect session, which the page describes as an initial discussion of a startup's immediate challenge. Note the page's own caution: a short consultation is not a full programme or deliverable unless specified. The Leadership Mentoring capability sets out how a fuller engagement works, and the contact page reaches the team directly.

Book a Startups: Quick Connect session

A short initial discussion of a startup's immediate challenge, booked and paid on Topmate and opened in a new tab.

Open booking on Topmate

Leadership Mentoring

One-to-one mentoring across strategy, product and growth, with a defined objective and clear next steps.

Explore the capability

Does leadership mentoring work?

What the research says about effect sizes, fit and why benefits can fade after a relationship ends.

Read the evidence review

Contact Lakhlani International

For a question that is not a booking, get in touch with the team.

Go to contact

Frequently asked questions

How many decisions should I bring to one session?

One or two. The Lakhlani International page suggests bringing one or two decisions you need to make, along with context, options considered and constraints.

Should I send my brief to the mentor in advance?

If the mentor accepts it, yes. It saves time on background and lets them think about your situation beforehand. Keep it to a page.

What if I do not have options yet?

Say so, and bring what you know and what you are assuming. Exploring the options can be the purpose of the session, but arriving with at least two usually makes it sharper.

How do I make sure the session leads to action?

End by stating the actions, owners, dates and the evidence you will gather, and set a checkpoint. Write them down within a day.

What should I do if I disagree with the mentor's advice?

Say so and ask why they see it that way. You are not obliged to follow advice, and a good mentor welcomes challenge. The decision remains yours.

Can mentoring replace professional legal, tax or investment advice?

No. Mentoring is not a substitute for appropriately qualified, regulated professional advice. Take that separately where a decision depends on it.

References

  • →St-Jean, É. and Tremblay, M. Mentoring for entrepreneurs: a boost or a crutch? Long-term effect of mentoring on self-efficacy. International Small Business Journal (2020). https://depot-e.uqtr.ca/id/eprint/9186/
  • →St-Jean, É., Radu-Lefebvre, M. and Mathieu, C. Can less be more? Mentoring functions, learning goal orientation, and novice entrepreneurs' self-efficacy. International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research (2018). https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/IJEBR-09-2016-0299/full/html
  • →Lakhlani International. Leadership Mentoring capability page. https://lakhlaniinternational.com/capabilities/mentoring

Related articles

Startup Ecosystem

Funding Readiness for Mumbai Startups and Scale-Ups: A Practical Guide to Getting Investor-Ready

Mayank N Lakhlani

How Mumbai startups and scale-ups can prepare to raise capital: funding options, India-specific due diligence, cap table and compliance basics, and a 90-day plan.

Read article→

Startup Ecosystem

When Does a Growth-Stage Mumbai Company Need a Fractional CTO or CXO?

Mayank N Lakhlani

Eight signals that a growth-stage Mumbai company needs a fractional CTO, CFO or other CXO, plus how to choose the role, scope the work and avoid common mistakes.

Read article→

Startup Ecosystem

Does Leadership Mentoring Work? What the Research Says and How to Get More From It

Mayank N Lakhlani

Mentoring is praised so often that sceptics are right to ask for evidence. Is it as useful as people say, for whom and under what conditions? The honest answer from the research is more modest, and more useful, than the slogans.

Read article→

Startup Ecosystem

Mentor, Coach, Adviser or Consultant: Which Kind of Leadership Support Fits Your Situation?

Mayank N Lakhlani

A leader looking for help will hear four labels used almost interchangeably: mentor, coach, adviser and consultant. They overlap in everyday speech, and providers use them in different ways. Choosing the wrong kind costs time and money, and can leave the real problem untouched.

Read article→

Startup Ecosystem

When Everything Feels Urgent: How Founders and Operators Can Prioritise Decisions and Pressure-Test Plans

Mayank N Lakhlani

A founder's week rarely arrives in a sensible order. A key customer is unhappy, a hire is pending, the roadmap is contested, a cash question looms and a partner wants an answer by Friday. Everything is labelled urgent, and the loudest request wins.

Read article→

Startup Ecosystem

What Is Leadership Mentoring? A Practical Guide for Founders and Operators

Mayank N Lakhlani

Most founders and new leaders reach a point where the hard problems are no longer technical. Which of three promising priorities comes first? How should a plan be tested before money is committed? Why does a team keep missing commitments? Advice is plentiful. Experienced, relevant, honest advice that fits your situation is much scarcer.

Read article→

Enjoyed this article?

Explore more ideas, research, and perspectives from the Knowledge Hub — or start a conversation with us.