Does Leadership Mentoring Work? What the Research Says and How to Get More From It
Mentoring is praised so often that sceptics are right to ask for evidence. Is it as useful as people say, for whom and under what conditions? The honest answer from the research is more modest, and more useful, than the slogans.
This article reviews the main studies, states their limits and draws practical lessons for founders and operators considering mentoring. It does not claim that any particular mentoring engagement, including Lakhlani International's, will produce a given result. The capability page makes no such claim either.
The big picture: favourable, but small
The most cited reviews are meta-analyses, which pool the results of many studies.
Eby, Allen, Evans, Ng and DuBois (2008), published in the Journal of Vocational Behavior, reviewed research across youth, academic and workplace mentoring and compared mentored with non-mentored people. They found mentoring associated with a wide range of favourable behavioural, attitudinal, health-related, relational, motivational and career outcomes, but the effect sizes were generally small. Effects were generally larger for academic and workplace mentoring than for youth mentoring.
Allen, Eby, Poteet, Lentz and Lima (2004), in the Journal of Applied Psychology, focused on career benefits. They found generally supportive results, but effects on objective outcomes such as compensation were small. Outcomes also differed by type of mentoring: career-focused help and psychosocial support related differently to outcomes.
Taken together, these say that mentoring is associated with benefits and that the benefits are typically modest. They do not say mentoring causes large improvements. Many of the studies compare people who chose or were selected for mentoring with those who were not, so other differences may explain part of the gap.
What makes mentoring better or worse
A later meta-analysis led by Eby and colleagues, published in Psychological Bulletin in 2013, pooled 173 samples and looked at what shapes the mentee's experience. As summarised by the British Psychological Society, it found that:
- →Relationships were stronger when mentor and mentee aligned on deep features such as values, and to a lesser extent on shared experiences.
- →Surface similarities such as age, race and gender were almost irrelevant in aggregate.
- →Regular, informal contact and having other supportive relationships helped.
- →For the typical mentee, the benefits were likely to be more limited in scope and size than sometimes claimed.
This summary draws on the British Psychological Society's digest of the study, so consult the paper itself before quoting specific findings.
What about entrepreneurs?
Entrepreneur-specific research is smaller, and it adds important nuance.
St-Jean and Tremblay (2020), in the International Small Business Journal, studied 219 novice entrepreneurs who had mentors, and followed up 106 of them over time. They examined self-efficacy in recognising opportunities. Mentoring supported it only for mentees with a low learning goal orientation, meaning people less focused on learning and mastery. For those mentees, the effect was ephemeral and decreased once the relationship ended. Mentees high in learning goal orientation saw their self-efficacy decline slightly during intense mentoring, which the authors suggest may reflect adjustment to a more appropriate level.
St-Jean, Radu-Lefebvre and Mathieu (2018), in the International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research, studied 360 novice Canadian entrepreneurs in a formal programme with volunteer mentors. Mentees with a high learning goal orientation reported lower self-efficacy as they received more in-depth mentoring. The authors note that their findings come from a formal programme with unpaid mentors and need testing in informal relationships.
The lesson is not that mentoring is harmful. Confidence is not the same as competence, and an experienced outsider can make a mentee more realistic. But it also suggests that a single measure of benefit, such as confidence, can mislead, and that what you get depends on who you are as a learner.
What the research cannot tell you
Be clear about the gaps.
- →Most studies concern formal programmes, employees or students, not paid one-to-one mentoring by operators, and none of the studies reviewed here concerns India specifically.
- →Many measure self-reported attitudes, not business results.
- →Associations are not proof of cause.
- →Small average effects hide large variation. Some relationships work very well and some do little.
- →There is no rigorous evidence that mentoring improves a venture's revenue, growth or funding outcomes, and no provider should promise that.
Lessons for getting more from mentoring
These are interpretations of the research and practical judgement, not proven rules.
- Start with a specific decision or gap. The Lakhlani International page does: a useful engagement starts with a real decision or capability gap and ends with clear next steps. Generic mentoring has the least to offer.
- Look for fit in thinking and values. Deeper alignment appears to matter more than surface similarity.
- Plan regular contact. Occasional conversations are less likely to build a working relationship.
- Prepare and follow through. Use a brief, capture actions and set checkpoints. The companion article on preparing for a mentoring session offers a template.
- Build your own capability. Evidence that benefits faded after the relationship ended is a reason to turn advice into skills, habits and documented decisions that stay with you.
- Keep other support. Other supportive relationships helped in the research. Mentoring should complement peers, advisers and professionals, not replace them.
- Measure your own progress. Agree what evidence will show whether it is helping, as the page's method suggests.
- Treat confidence carefully. A session that makes you less sure may be doing useful work.
An illustrative scenario (hypothetical)
Consider a hypothetical founder who has had several mentoring conversations and feels better each time but cannot name a decision that changed. Reviewing the research, she realises her sessions have been general, infrequent and without follow-up. She changes the approach: one decision per session, a written brief beforehand, a short list of actions afterwards and a review of results at the next meeting.
Six weeks later she can point to three decisions, the assumptions behind them and what she learned from each. The mentoring has not become magical. It has become specific and accountable to her own records. This scenario is invented for illustration and does not describe any client.
The bottom line
The research supports a measured view. Mentoring is associated with favourable outcomes, the average effects are small, and results depend on the relationship, the mentee and how the mentoring is used. If you try it, make it specific, regular and followed through, keep realistic expectations and take regulated advice separately where needed.
If you want a focused conversation about an immediate decision, you can book a Startups: Quick Connect session. To explore further, read about the Leadership Mentoring capability or get in touch with the team.
Book a Startups: Quick Connect session
A short initial discussion of a startup's immediate challenge, booked and paid on Topmate and opened in a new tab.
Open booking on TopmateLeadership Mentoring
One-to-one mentoring across strategy, product and growth, starting from a real decision or capability gap.
Explore the capabilityHow to prepare for a mentoring session
The one-page brief that turns a general conversation into decisions, actions and checkpoints.
Read the preparation guideContact Lakhlani International
For a question that is not a booking, get in touch with the team.
Go to contactFrequently asked questions
Is there evidence that mentoring works?
Meta-analyses find mentoring is associated with a wide range of favourable outcomes, but effect sizes are generally small. The evidence is largely correlational and mostly from formal programmes, so it does not guarantee results for any individual.
Does mentoring improve business results for founders?
There is no rigorous evidence showing that mentoring improves a venture's revenue, growth or funding outcomes. Studies of entrepreneurs focus mainly on attitudes such as self-efficacy, so treat claims of business results with caution.
Why might mentoring benefits fade?
One study of novice entrepreneurs found the effect on one measure of confidence decreased once the relationship ended. Turning advice into your own skills, habits and written decisions may help benefits last, though that is an interpretation, not a proven remedy.
Does it matter who my mentor is?
Yes, but surface similarities such as age or gender appear to matter little. Research summaries point to alignment on deeper features such as values and approach, regular contact and relationship quality.
How often should I meet a mentor?
There is no research-based number. Regular, informal contact was associated with stronger relationships, so choose a rhythm you will keep, and agree it at the start.
Is mentoring worth it if effects are small?
It depends on your situation and the cost. A small average effect can still be valuable if the relationship fits and you use it well. Set a clear objective and review whether it is helping.
References
- →Eby, L., Allen, T., Evans, S., Ng, T. and DuBois, D. Does Mentoring Matter? A Multidisciplinary Meta-Analysis Comparing Mentored and Non-Mentored Individuals. Journal of Vocational Behavior (2008). https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/psy_facpub/23/
- →Allen, T., Eby, L., Poteet, M., Lentz, E. and Lima, L. Career benefits associated with mentoring for protégés: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology (2004). https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14769125/
- →British Psychological Society Research Digest. When and how does mentoring matter? Summary of Eby et al., Psychological Bulletin (2013). https://bps.org.uk/research-digest/when-and-how-does-mentoring-matter
- →St-Jean, É. and Tremblay, M. Mentoring for entrepreneurs: a boost or a crutch? International Small Business Journal (2020). https://depot-e.uqtr.ca/id/eprint/9186/
- →St-Jean, É., Radu-Lefebvre, M. and Mathieu, C. Can less be more? International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research (2018). https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/IJEBR-09-2016-0299/full/html
- →Lakhlani International. Leadership Mentoring capability page. https://lakhlaniinternational.com/capabilities/mentoring