What Is Business Strategy? A Practical Guide for Founders and Leadership Teams
Most leadership teams have a plan, a budget and a set of goals. Fewer can say, in two or three sentences, what they have chosen to do differently from competitors, what they have decided not to do, and why. That second question is where strategy lives, and it is why so many documents called strategies turn out to be wish lists.
This guide explains what business strategy is, the structure that distinguishes a real strategy from a list of ambitions, and how to begin when you are facing a specific decision.
A working definition
Business strategy is a reasoned choice about how an organisation will compete or create value in the face of a specific challenge, together with the coordinated actions that follow from that choice. Three ideas sit inside that sentence.
- →It is a choice. Strategy means selecting some options and ruling out others.
- →It responds to a specific challenge. A strategy detached from a real problem is a statement of intent.
- →It leads to coordinated action. A choice that does not change what people do is not yet a strategy.
Lakhlani International's capability page frames the work the same way: it begins with the decision to be made and the evidence available.
The kernel: diagnosis, guiding policy, coherent action
Strategy scholar Richard Rumelt, in Good Strategy/Bad Strategy (2011), argues that a good strategy has a kernel of three parts.
Diagnosis
An explicit account of the challenge: what is actually going on, and which factors matter most. A good diagnosis simplifies a messy situation by identifying the critical issue. Rumelt treats it as the part most often skipped.
Guiding policy
The overall approach chosen to deal with the diagnosed challenge. It is not a goal or a vision. It is a way of tackling the problem that also rules out many possible actions.
Coherent action
A set of coordinated steps that carry out the guiding policy, so that each one supports the others rather than pulling in a different direction.
A simple way to test your own strategy: can someone outside the company read your diagnosis and judge whether the policy and actions follow from it? If the logic is not visible on the page, it is probably not yet a strategy.
Position, trade-offs and the limits of operational improvement
Michael Porter's 1996 Harvard Business Review article "What Is Strategy?" adds a second lens. Porter distinguishes operational effectiveness, which means performing similar activities better than rivals, from strategy, which means choosing a distinctive position built on a different set of activities.
Two implications follow. First, becoming faster, cheaper or more efficient is necessary but rarely distinctive, because competitors can copy best practice. Second, a position is only sustainable if it involves trade-offs: things you deliberately will not do, so that rivals cannot simply match you without giving something up.
For a founder, that translates into practical questions. Whom are we serving, and whom are we not serving? What will we do that others will not, and what will we decline to do?
What strategy is not
Several things are commonly mistaken for strategy.
- →A goal. "Reach a certain revenue by next year" describes an outcome, not an approach to getting there.
- →A vision or mission statement. These express aspiration. They do not choose between options.
- →A budget. Money follows strategy. A budget without a strategy simply reproduces last year.
- →A list of initiatives. Ten unconnected projects are not coherent action; they are ten bets competing for the same people.
- →Operational improvement. Valuable, but not a substitute for choosing a position.
What a strategy engagement should produce
The output of strategy work should help leaders decide and act. According to the Lakhlani International capability page, an engagement can produce:
- A structured business problem and decision brief.
- Customer, market and positioning hypotheses to validate.
- A business model and priority initiative map.
- A sequenced roadmap with assumptions, risks and success measures.
The emphasis on hypotheses and validation is deliberate. Strategy is an educated judgement made with incomplete information, so the honest output is a set of assumptions to test, not a guarantee. The page is explicit that no responsible engagement can guarantee revenue growth.
An illustrative scenario (hypothetical)
Imagine a hypothetical founder of a small software business with several product ideas, a handful of customers in different industries and a plan to "grow 3x". The plan lists new features, a sales hire and a rebrand.
Applying the kernel, the founder would first diagnose: most revenue comes from one type of customer who values a specific workflow, while the other customers churn quickly. The guiding policy might be to focus on that customer type and decline custom work for others. Coherent actions would then follow: prioritise features for that workflow, hire sales experience in that segment and postpone the rebrand. The scenario is invented for illustration and does not describe any client.
Signs your organisation needs strategy work
- →You cannot describe your target customer and their problem in a sentence.
- →Your offer sounds like your competitors'.
- →Several growth initiatives compete for the same people and budget.
- →Product, technology and sales teams are working from different assumptions.
These match the problems listed on the capability page, and each is the subject of a later article in this series.
Where to start
Write down the single decision you most need to make in the next quarter. Next, list what evidence you have and what you are assuming. Then draft a diagnosis in a few sentences, and ask a colleague to challenge it. That is a better first step than a strategy offsite with no defined question.
If you want a structured outside view, Lakhlani International's Business Strategy capability is built around that decision-first approach. You can discuss a project or read about the startup ecosystem the firm supports.
Business Strategy
Structured support for founders and leadership teams working through a specific business decision: positioning, priorities and a sequenced roadmap.
Explore the Business Strategy capabilityDiscuss a project
Start with the decision you need to make and the evidence you already have.
Discuss a ProjectFrequently asked questions
What is the difference between strategy and a business plan?
A strategy is the reasoned choice about how to meet a challenge. A business plan is a broader document that may include the strategy along with operations, finances and timelines. A plan without a strategy lists activities without explaining why they were chosen.
Does a small business need a business strategy?
Yes, though it can be brief. Small organisations have limited time and money, which makes choosing what not to do more important, not less. A short written diagnosis, policy and set of actions is enough to start.
What are the main elements of a business strategy?
A diagnosis of the challenge, a guiding policy and coherent actions form a useful core. Most practitioners also define the target customer, the value proposition, the business model and the measures of progress.
How often should we revisit our strategy?
Whenever the diagnosis changes, such as a new competitor, a shift in customer behaviour or a failed assumption, and at planned review points. Documenting assumptions makes it clear what to check.
Is operational excellence a strategy?
Not on its own. Porter's view is that operational effectiveness is necessary but competitors can copy it. Strategy requires a distinctive position and trade-offs, with operational excellence in support.
Can a consultant guarantee growth from a strategy?
No. A responsible engagement makes assumptions explicit and defines measurable actions and review points, but it cannot guarantee a commercial outcome.
References
- →Porter, M. What Is Strategy? Harvard Business Review, November to December 1996. https://hbr.org/1996/11/what-is-strategy
- →Rumelt, R. Good Strategy/Bad Strategy: The Difference and Why It Matters (2011).
- →Lakhlani International. Business Strategy capability page. https://lakhlaniinternational.com/capabilities/business-strategy