Too Many Growth Ideas, Too Little Budget: How to Prioritise Initiatives
Every growing business has more ideas than capacity. A new market, a feature request from a big customer, a rebrand, a partnership, a hire: each has a champion and a plausible case. The danger is not choosing badly. It is choosing nothing, so that effort is spread thinly across everything.
This article offers a way to compare competing initiatives using the four criteria that Lakhlani International's Business Strategy page names: evidence, value, risk and feasibility. It also covers the harder half of prioritisation, which is deciding what to stop.
Why prioritisation is a strategic act
Prioritisation is sometimes treated as scheduling. It is closer to strategy itself, because every choice to fund one thing is a choice not to fund another.
McKinsey research on large companies offers a relevant signal. Studies it cites show that companies that actively reallocate resources outperform those that do not. Its survey of more than 500 companies found that obstacles such as cognitive bias and inconsistent decision processes keep many from being as active as they could be. Higher performers tended to use clear, consistently applied criteria and to wind down projects quickly when targets were missed.
The caveats are important. This research concerns mostly large companies, it shows association rather than proof of cause, and a start-up's situation differs. The transferable idea is simpler: decide using explicit criteria, and be willing to stop things.
The four criteria
Evidence
How strong is the support for the assumption that this will work? Use the ladder from the previous article in this series: opinion is weak, observed behaviour is stronger, customer commitment is strongest.
Value
If it works, how large is the benefit, and to what measure? Express value in terms the organisation uses, such as revenue, margin, retention or time saved, with the basis for any estimate stated.
Risk
What could go wrong, and how bad would it be? Consider commercial, technical, financial and reputational risk, and how reversible the decision is.
Feasibility
Can the team deliver it with the people, skills, technology and time available? An attractive initiative that needs capacity you do not have is not yet a real option.
A simple scoring approach
Score each initiative from 1 to 5 on each criterion, with reasons recorded. A working table has these columns:
Scoring template
- →Initiative: the proposal being compared.
- →Evidence: 1 to 5, from opinion at the low end to customer commitment at the high end.
- →Value: 1 to 5, with the basis for the estimate stated.
- →Risk: 1 to 5, where 5 means low risk.
- →Feasibility: 1 to 5, given the people, skills, technology and time available.
- →Notes and assumptions: the reasoning behind the scores.
Four cautions keep the exercise honest.
- Scores are judgements, not facts. The value is in the discussion and in surfacing disagreement.
- Weight criteria deliberately. If cash is tight, you may weight risk and feasibility more heavily than value.
- Do not add numbers blindly. A high-value initiative with no evidence deserves a test before a full commitment, however high the total.
- Score independently first. Have each leader score separately, then compare, so that the loudest voice does not set the numbers.
Turn scores into decisions
A ranked list is not yet a decision. Group initiatives into four outcomes:
- →Do now: strong evidence, solid value, acceptable risk, feasible.
- →Test first: high potential but weak evidence. Run a small experiment with a clear threshold before committing.
- →Defer: reasonable, but capacity or dependencies are not ready.
- →Stop or decline: low evidence or value, or high risk relative to benefit.
The capability page frames the work as prioritising actions by evidence, value, risk and feasibility, then documenting decisions and the next validation milestones. The documentation matters: it lets you revisit a decision when assumptions change.
Build a stop list
Teams find it easy to add initiatives and hard to remove them. Drucker's observation, recounted by the Drucker Institute, is that concentrating resources on results always requires saying no to projects and people that previously had backing. Because that is uncomfortable, make it routine.
- →Review active initiatives at set intervals against the measures you agreed at the start.
- →Set a stop condition when you start each one: what result by what date would cause you to end it.
- →Treat sunk cost as irrelevant. What matters is the expected value of the next unit of effort.
- →Reallocate freed capacity visibly, so that stopping one thing is seen as enabling another.
Common traps
- →Choosing by seniority or enthusiasm rather than criteria.
- →Counting a long list of small initiatives as progress.
- →Ignoring dependencies, such as a campaign that relies on a product feature not yet built.
- →Underestimating capacity constraints in a small team.
- →Treating a one-off exercise as permanent. Reprioritise when evidence changes.
An illustrative scenario (hypothetical)
Consider a hypothetical B2B services company with six proposals: a new geography, a customer portal, a partner programme, a pricing change, a rebrand and a new service line. Scoring shows that the pricing change has solid evidence from existing customers, moderate value and low risk. The new service line has high potential but weak evidence. The rebrand scores low on evidence and value at present.
The leadership team decides to do the pricing change now, run a small paid pilot of the new service line, defer the portal until a dependency is resolved, and stop the rebrand for this year. The decisions and their reasons are written down with dates for review. This scenario is invented for illustration and does not describe any client.
When outside perspective helps
Outside input is useful when the leadership team is divided, when the criteria are unclear or when the issue is sensitive. Lakhlani International's Business Strategy capability includes a business model and priority initiative map, with assumptions, risks and success measures. It does not promise commercial outcomes.
Operational initiatives sometimes fit better under the firm's Digital Transformation capability. Once priorities are chosen, the next step is turning them into an aligned plan: the growth roadmap.
How to build a growth roadmap
The next article in this series: aligning product, technology and commercial plans around stated assumptions.
Read the roadmap guideDigital Transformation
For operational initiatives that need process, platform or customer-experience change rather than strategy work.
Explore Digital TransformationFrequently asked questions
How do I choose between several good growth ideas?
Compare them on the same criteria: evidence, value, risk and feasibility. Score independently, discuss differences and record reasons. Then group the ideas into do now, test first, defer and stop.
How many initiatives should a small team run at once?
Fewer than seems comfortable. The right number depends on capacity, but a small team spreading across many initiatives usually delivers none well. Start with the number you can resource properly and expand only as capacity frees up.
What should I do with an idea that has high potential but weak evidence?
Run a small, time-limited test with a pre-agreed success threshold. This turns an argument about potential into evidence, at a fraction of the cost of a full commitment.
How often should we review priorities?
At regular intervals and whenever key assumptions change. Many teams review quarterly, but the cadence should reflect how quickly your market and evidence move.
Is scoring too simplistic for strategic decisions?
Scoring is a structure for discussion, not an algorithm. It is most useful for exposing hidden disagreements and making reasoning explicit. Use judgement for the final call.
How do we decide what to stop?
Set stop conditions when initiatives begin, review against agreed measures, ignore sunk costs and reallocate freed resources openly. Making stopping routine reduces the emotional cost.
References
- →McKinsey Quarterly. Admit it, your investments are stuck in neutral. https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/admit-it-your-investments-are-stuck-in-neutral
- →Bradley, C., Hirt, M. and Smit, S. How to make the bold strategy moves that matter (McKinsey, on Strategy Beyond the Hockey Stick, 2018). https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/how-to-make-the-bold-strategy-moves-that-matter
- →Drucker Institute. A Deadly Temptation (account of Drucker on concentrating resources). https://drucker.institute/?p=16683
- →Lakhlani International. Business Strategy capability page. https://lakhlaniinternational.com/capabilities/business-strategy